Grete
Stern (born in Wuppertal, Germany in 1904) came to Argentina in 1935, in
exile from the nazi regime. By then she was a graphic designer and an accomplished
photographer, formed at the School for Applied Arts, in Stuttgart, and at
Walter Peterhans's workshops privately at first, then at the Bauhaus in
Dessau. Most of Grete's work in Germany was carried out at the ringl + pit
studio she had set up with her friend Ellen Auerbach, and has recently been
enthusiastically appraised by European and American critics, as well as
by scholars. But the bulk of her production - both as to importance and
quantity was carried out in our country over nearly fifty years of uninterrupted
activity. Her work, remarkable in quality and variety of genres, had not
previously been collected into book form nor described and reviewed, as
undertaken in this volume. Grete Stern, formed in the refined, creative
European vanguard of the twenties, is an essential artist in modern Argentine
photography, and she has contributed decisively to founding it.
In 1948 she received an original
proposal: supplying photographs to illustrate a section of Idilio
magazine, published by Abril, entitled "El psicoanálisis
le ayudara" (Psychoanalysis will help you). Edited by sociologist
Gino Germani under de penname of Richard Rest, it conveyed psychoanalytical
views on the dreams of its women correspondents. Grete proposed illustrating
the dreams with photomontages. Her collaboration lasted around three years,
in the course of which over one hundred and fifty pieces were published.
To our knowledge, this is the largest and most important series of photomontages
made in our country.
It is an acknowledged fact
that modern photomontage, developed in Germany after the First World War,
was applied to political propaganda, advertising, and experimental photography.
Grete imbibed it first during her apprenticeship as a graphic designer and
then as a photographer. As already mentioned, it was a creative procedure
she found attractive and inspiring. Up to the time of her Idilio
series, Grete's photomontages in Argentina had been few and
occasional.
The texts describing the dreams
to be illustrated by Grete were provided by Germani. Usually, they strictly
reproduced the letters sent in by readers. Grete and Germani used to talk
over the letter's intended interpretation, and he would request that the
layout show certain characteristics, that flowers or animals be depicted,
or unstable shapes, or some figures performing certain actions. Thence Grete
would develop her combinative creation and her own point of view on the
subject, which resulted in pieces of fairly free invention.
Each photomontage was published
with a title:"Ambition dreams', "Mask dreams", "Dreams
of discontent", and so on, plus a comment written by Germani. The comments
referred to the image composed by Grete as though it were a literal illustration
of the dream described by the reader; based on it Germani produced interpretations
and recommendations.
The leading character in the
photomontages was of course Idilio's reader - Germani's correspondent
- who belonged to the lower classes in our country, especially the rising
middle class of President Per6n's first years in office. That female character
is present in the images, either explicitly or implicitly: she takes part
in her own dream or "looks on through the viewfinder, as happens
in subjective movie footage.
The subject matter originated
in the dreams Germani found to be the most interesting for his analyzing,
and among these main lythe ones emphasizing anguish and conflict. Grete's
idea of female independence was very strong, and her critical attitude with
respect to dominant values constraining and limiting it was a part of her
idiosyncrasy. The possibility of expressing her viewpoints on these issues
through her photomontages therefore came natural to her.
Practical requirements were
met with domestic resources: Grete's actors were friends, relatives and
neighbors, while the complementary images - landscapes, backgrounds, objects,
secondary characters - came from her own files. It meant hard work, as she
had to produce one photomontage a week - which left little time for correcting
or retouching it. This explains why at least four photomontages were altered
after publication, so that there are two renderings of each of those dreams:
the one published in Idilio and the one in the photographer's
archives. In all cases the latter is the better.
Grete's dream woman
is an anguished, oppressed being. Her pleasures are as pathetic as her frustrations;
when she is shown to be active and dominant, she is as cruel as the world
that burdens her. Her ambitions mirror soap-opera and melodrama utopias:
social success, wealth, long gloves, lame. Bottled
up on the seaside, her destiny is uncertain and hazardous, no matter
whether she has been washed ashore by the tide after a long journey, or
the trip is yet to begin. An unknown hand has tossed - or will toss - her
into the sea, for an unknown, uncertain hand to pick her up. The message
is desperate: a moan or a scream arising from solitude for someone to hear
it. Nevertheless, she smiles as she looks up atthe sky. She also smiles
upon being wrapped up in the net her lover has thrown in by the window.
She looks transported, enraptured, as her beautiful hair turned into paintbrush bristles is driven by the hand of her man
(who else's could it be?) in order to daub paint on a wall. And then, proud
of her figure, she poses statuette-like to serve as a night-lamp
bottom on her man's night-table. A service object, decoration object, useful
object: in any case a predicament that pleases her without wounding her.
Her dismembered body, maimed, or made manifold, frequently appears in the
series, and even if there is something comical about the surreal tone of
the two hands emerging from
the water to grab her flesh, the overall sense of consentedto and enjoyed
manipulation in which the image is set renders it dramatic. In children's
images beauty and peace may arrive. The baby blooming in the lily against a bucolic
background is held by the hand of the leading character in the series. The
latter is looking at the baby and enjoying it - much as we are - through
the viewfinder. Another peaceful area in the collection is made up of compositions
with a metaphysical trend. There the female character's maimed body dismisses
its physical rotundness and is changed into a transparent, diluted sketch,
almost a variegated sky - one among other heavenly bodies.
In my opinion, the series
of photomontages for Idilio has been the first - and the most important
- photography work radically critical of the oppression and manipulation
endured by women in Argentine society over that time, and of the humiliating
consequence of consented-to submissiveness. Grete's gaze, mocking and sarcastic,
does not rest at being compassionate towards the victim: it goes further
on into the alienating results of her resignation. The fact that this material
was presented in the leading romance magazine published in the country adds
a touch of humor and irony to it.
The dreams set shows
Grete as a true artist and vanguard woman. In her friendly, quiet style
she has conducted her life in a spirit of independence, both radical and
coherent, with respect to dominant values and habits -the same spirit shown
in her photomontages. Within the entire work produced by Grete, the dreams
represent the chapter where her opinions on the subject at hand are
more clearly present in the invention of the image. This does not entail
a rationalist invasion of the compositions. Her montages do not illustrate
prior ideas, and their capacity to persuade is always plastic. However,
their effect at once leads us to reflections of a moral order on the subject-matter,
proving in an indirect if certain way that similar thoughts have prompted
them.
In spite of their being published
weekly for nearly three years, the photomontages failed to raise any comments
during that period. Probably the want of intellectual prestige of magazines
such as Idilio had to do with it. Besides, photography reviewing
in the mass media did not exist, and montage lacked the artistic prestige
that might have moved art critics to review the dreams. As a matter
of fact, they were not reviewed even in 1967, when they were exhibited at
the Foto Club Argentino salon. The truth remains that Grete's photomontages
have meant original work among the Argentine photographic activity of the
time, even if a k unprejudiced gaze was required to be able to see this.
Grete's dreams were
for the first time presented as independent photographs by the end of the
fifties at the Faculty of Psycho of La Plata University. They were first
displayed in Buenos Aires in 1967, with the collaboration of poet
Elva de Loizaga. From then up to 1982, when they hung at the great FotoFest
show at Hous U.S.A., only art collector Jorge Helft took notice of them.
FotoFest their prestige grew sharply, to the extent that they now rated
at their original and true significance.
Fragments from Luis Priamo at: Grete Stern: Obra fotográfica
en la Argentina, Fondo Nacional de las Artes, Argentina, 1995.
|